So you have planned a big night out and have decided to adorn a pair of your favorite eyelash extensions, but to make the extensions stand out and look beautiful, you will need eyeliner. In this article, we have listed the water based eyeliner for eyelash extensions, along with how to apply, and care for your extensions as well.
If you have ever worn eyelash extensions, you will know that oil-based products and glue don’t go together, and the same goes for glitter formulas too. The eyeliners that are listed below are based on their intensity and defining elements. All the brands listed here are safe to use and will not cause any harm to your precious lashes.
The water based mascara brands that are listed below are based on reviews from customers and beauty bloggers so there are definitely worth a try!
Best water based eyeliner for eyelash extensions:
Sigma Beauty 306 winged liner brush with Bobbi Brown Downtown Cool Eye Shadow Palette::
This duo is known to create a sense of depth to your eyeshadow; it darkens the lids and highlights the brows, resulting in the perfect smoky eye. Priced at 14 dollars and 34 dollars respectively, these products give a clear and defined line. You can also opt for gel liners. You may think that it’s a bit pricey, but quality always comes at a price, and it’s better to consider it as an investment. The steeply aligned brush will help you draw that perfect wing you’ve always wanted to get, and it also gives you excellent grip while at work. “This is an amazing winged liner brush. It gets the point of the wing so precise, and there is no tug when I use this. I can’t believe I was ever able to do a wing without it. I’ve tried others that were cheaper, and they couldn’t do what this one could. This one is worth the money, and when comparing to other more expensive brands, this one is a great value!” says an Amazon customer.
The Bobbi Brown Downtown Cool Eye Shadow Palette comes with four colors including black and dark brown. It is perfect for you to use it as a liner if you want to attain a subtle look that looks a bit like a shadow rather than a well-defined line. The colors are densely pigmented, and they always come in handy when you’re working on the smokey eye look. You don’t have to worry about the money that you’re spending on this palette because it is going to be worthy of it. The product is of high quality since it is manufactured by Bobbi Brown, one of the most trusted cosmetic brands in the world.
Urban Decay Glide-On Eye Pencil:
Priced at 20 dollars this product is available on the Urban Decay website as well as on Amazon. It’s very popular because of the creamy lasting formula and the fact that it is available in a variety of colors. The eyeliner has moisturizing ingredients like Jojoba oil, Vitamin E, and Cottonseed oil and does not leave any pesky residue behind. It is an amazing liner if you want to play that lash game well, without hurting your eyelids or the sensitive area around your eyes. Silvana Seymour, a user of the product reviews it as, “This pencil is wonderful for my eyes, I had an allergy to all the other marks this an excellent pencil for my eyes.”
Benefit ‘They’re Real’ Push up Liner:
This product has quite the fan following and comes in vibrant shades of blue, green, brown, and black. Pair this with Benefit’s water-based mascara, and you have a perfect look. The eyeliner comes in the form of a pen which makes application easy. There are no parabens in the formula, so it’s safe for your eyes. “This is the best eyeliner of the market, and you need to apply once and stays on all day. It’s easy to apply. To remove the eyeliner, you need to use the They’re real mascara and eyeliner remover or any other product that is similar. You won’t be able to take it out with water,” says an Amazon customer. It is oil free, and you can use it with eyelash extensions.
Stila Smudge pot:
Pair this pot with a sigma beauty brush and draw winged eyeliner with zero effort. The best feature about this gel-based eyeliner is that you don’t have to stick to a line; you can use the brush to smudge it out a bit and create a sultry look for the perfect night out. Most of us use eyelash extensions when we want to catch some eyes, and that’s precisely why I think the Smudge Pot will be a great option to be used as a liner when you have eyelash extensions on.
“This is my favorite brown eyeliner. It never smudges and lasts all day. I use a flat tipped eyeliner brush to tap it on rather than using a stroking motion, and then I use a cotton swab to smudge and blend the color. The pigment is very intense, so a little goes a long way if using it for eyeshadow. As others have mentioned, it does dry out eventually, but it lasts for months, so I buy a new one when that happens,” says Sophia Rossano, a happy customer on Amazon. Mary, another customer, reviews the product as “I’ve not found Stila products disappointing. This liner (with the proper brush) goes on smooth and stays all day. I wear it for my Zumba class and running. The color stays in place — no running, no smearing. Love their products!”
Maybelline Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner:
This gel-based eyeliner has made quite the impact ever since it was launched. This versatile eyeliner remains intact for the entire day and is smudge proof. You can rock that cat eye flawlessly with the brush that is provided with the pot. Gentle reminder: keep the lid on at all times. It is dermatologist as well as allergy tested so you can trust the product wholeheartedly. This one’s for the perfect stays inside the line kind of liner that doesn’t smudge and give you a smokey look. It gives you a clean and classy look that you can wear to work or college every day. Well, the clean part isn’t entirely true since we can draw an amazing pair of cat eyes with this liner *wink*
This is what Emily, a user of the product has to say “I tend to avoid pencils that have to be sharpened and prefer retractable ones instead. I decided to give this pencil a try anyway and am super impressed with how smoothly and easily this goes on. I’ve never found a pencil that could glide on like this one without ‘skipping’ some areas. I haven’t had any trouble with sharpening it like a lot of the other reviews state, and I use a good makeup pencil sharpener. This probably isn’t the best pencil if you want a very fine line for your liner, but I believe that’s why the name includes “drama.” The products in this line tend to be a bit bolder, accentuating certain features. You will get a bolder look with this pencil.”
Bare minerals Lash domination Ink liner:
If you do not like the whole pot and brush combination and want something that is easy to handle, then the bare minerals liner is perfect. The felt tip may give it a sketch pen feel, but the pen consists of a thick, black formula that glides onto your lid effortlessly. “One of the best eyeliners I’ve ever used. I apply a heavy cat-eye daily- the fine tip and smooth application ensure a zero mess, precise, and fast process. Water resistant and lasts all day. Relatively low toxicity as well, which is hard to find in a good eyeliner,” says Kaitlyn Lauinger, a user of the product.
Now that we’ve discussed the best eyeliners that can be used with or without eyelash extensions, I would love to introduce you to two of the best water-based mascara that you would find useful when you have eyelash extensions on:
Maybelline Great Lash
Called as “America’s favorite mascara,” this pink and green bottle is the personal asset of every woman there is. There are washable and waterproof variants of this mascara, and if you want to apply it over your eyelash extensions, you have to go for the washable one. Washable mascaras are usually oil-free which is what we’re looking for, over here. Oil-based and clumpy mascara makes the roots of the eyelash extensions loose and spoils their adherence capacity. The product was launched in 1971 and is still on top of the mascara game. Why is that? Now, you do the thinking.
“I am very pleased with this product! While I have always worn the blackest mascara I could find, I’ve recently developed an obnoxious allergy: the skin beneath *one* lower lid was becoming puffy, red, itchy, and scaly. So strange – and definitely *not* the look I’m going for! I decided to try something I haven’t used since junior high, as an alternative: this clear mascara! After curling my lashes, I’m pleased to report that it’s more effective than I thought it would be. It definitely makes a difference and holds a curl. It doesn’t cause any irritation and feels quite soothing to apply. As long as I pair it with my favorite black eyeliner, I’m good to go! Definitely give it a try, if your regular mascara starts to disagree with you!” says Alyssa, a user of the product.
Benefit Bad Gal Mascara
The product claims to contain aero-particles that are derived from space technology. These particles are very light but well efficient in adding volume to your lashes or your eyelash extensions. It can be used with or without eyelash extensions, and it is formulated with provitamin B5 to nourish your eyelashes. It doesn’t smudge or become flaky and stays on for 36 hours without causing any problems. An Amazon customer reviewed the product as “I received a sample of this in a Birchbox. I have thin, short lashes with hooded eyes. I’ve tried all kinds of mascaras over the years from cheap to mega expensive. This is hands down the best mascara I have ever used! Literally, it can be done in two strokes! Long lashes that don’t smudge with tears eyes, no dotting anywhere either. I LOVE IT!!”
How to apply water-based eyeliner for eyelash extensions:
If you are someone who is obsessed with eyeliner and believes that any makeup look is incomplete without the perfect cat eye, then you will understand how important it is to pair water-based eyeliner with eyelash extensions.
Since there is nothing worse than getting your extensions messed up because you chose the wrong eyeliner. Lash expert Skyy Hadley has given some of the best advice on how to apply eyeliner with lash extensions.
Avoid Waterproof liners:
Always opt for a liner that is water ‘based’ and not water ‘proof.’ The reason you should avoid waterproof liners is that the removal process can be frustrating. The constant rubbing can cause you to shorten your lashes and lose some of your natural lashes too.
Patience is the key to getting that perfect flick. Always be careful, don’t run the liner too hard against the lash line. If applied aggressively the lashes will come loose and fall out. Use eyeliner that has a soft brush.
Less is more:
This is one lash commandment that all women should live by, and it is essential that you wear eyeliner that does not need to be removed aggressively and cause build up around the lashes.
It is vital, just like any other makeup product, to remove your eyeliner at the end of the day. This is because the product will build up around your lash extensions that will affect their durability and also result in raccoon eyes. Do not use oil-based makeup removers, always go for Micellar water because it is gentle on the skin and makeup comes off with minimal effort.
When using water based eyeliner for eyelash extensions, always be sure that the products you use are safe and suitable for your skin type; it should pair well with your lashes. Hopefully, you can pair your lash extensions with the perfect eyeliner, and you can check out our guide to take care of your eyelashes, happy shopping!
Which is your favorite eyeliner and mascara that you pair with eyelash extensions? Let us know your tips and tricks about your eye makeup routine in the comments section below.