Makeup companies like Maybelline and so on have heard your lash woes and have come up with oil-free water based best mascaras for eyelash extension. If you are someone who is obsessed with lash extensions, you will relate to the fact that you can almost never pair it with your favorite mascara, because you fear that the glue will come apart and your lashes will fall out. Read on to find the best water based mascaras that you can effortlessly pair with your lash extensions.
When you try on lash extensions you feel glamorous and they help enhance the beauty of your eyes, but pairing a good mascara with your lashes can take your eye makeup game to the next level. Before we roll out the list for the best water based mascaras, here are a few suggestions on how to use mascara when you have extensions on.
- Be gentle, and only focus on the ends where there is no glue. If you take the mascara to the roots you will rip out your extensions along with some of your natural lashes as well. So, stick to the ends to avoid this painful endeavor.
- Use a dry spoolie and gently lift and detangle the lashes, even if you are not planning to use mascara this gives your lashes a full and fluttery look.
- Don’t use waterproof mascara because it contains oil, this can break down the glue in your extensions and cause the lashes to fall apart.
Now moving onto the best mascaras for eyelash extension:
1. Maybelline Great Lash: Best mascaras for eyelash extension
Now water based mascara Maybelline is an absolute classic, launched in the 70s and still rocking the eye makeup industry with its evergreen formula, this affordable product is perfect to pair with your extensions all at a price of 9 dollars. There are no complex ingredients in this product just enough of it to give you a soft and flattering look. The product is easily available on Amazon. It is also considered best mascaras for eyelash extensions since it is water based and will not trouble the glue that is used to stick the eyelash extensions.
“I am very pleased with this product! While I have always worn the blackest mascara I could find, I’ve recently developed an obnoxious allergy: the skin beneath *one* lower lid was becoming puffy, red, itchy, and scaly. So strange – and definitely *not* the look I’m going for! I decided to try something I haven’t used since junior high, as an alternative: this clear mascara! After curling my lashes, I’m pleased to report that it’s more effective than I thought it would be. It definitely makes a difference and holds a curl. It doesn’t cause any irritation and actually feels quite soothing to apply. As long as I pair it with my favorite black eyeliner, I’m good to go! Definitely give it a try, if your regular mascara starts to disagree with you!” says Alyssa, a customer on Amazon.
2. Benefit Bad Gal Mascara:
Priced at 29 dollars this best mascaras for eyelash extension is absolutely wonderful and provides you with thick dramatic lashes that can be worn as a daytime look and for an exciting night out. Paired with your extensions this will make your eyes pop! Since it has the false lash effect, just a few swipes along with your lash extensions will give you the look of a showstopper. It comes with a tapered comb brush that will help in coating the product evenly on all of your eyelashes, even the ones in the corners. This product is available on Amazon.
Brock, a customer on Amazon, reviewed the product as “I’m 55 years old and had stopped wearing mascara years ago. No matter what I did, curled, heated curl, different brands, used clear or white pre-coat, my lashes looked like spikes … sticking straight out and scary. So, reading the reviews for this product was an “oh well, I’ve blown many dollars on other mascaras, what’s one more donation to the cosmetic companies.” Boy was I surprised and extremely pleased when my spikes curled and looked like girl lashes with just one application! No curling, just put it on and it’s lashes.”
3. Clinique Naturally Glossy Mascara:
This water-based safe mascara brand is the perfect choice because it will leave your lashes looking stronger and longer with just two swipes. Clinique is really famous because of its skin-friendly products and hence, it’s one of the best mascaras for eyelash extension. People love that they can use these products without any fear of developing a rash or any kind of eye/skin allergies. The same goes for their mascara as well; it’s water based and will not harm the eyes in any way. Not only is it completely oil free, it’s also paraben free. This product is available on Amazon.
“Very good mascara for sensitive eyes. Doesn’t clog and looks very natural,” says Malojakew, a user. You can wear this mascara every day since it is easily washable. Also, due to its oil-free formula, it can be used on eyelash extensions. This product gives your lashes a glow which is a unique feature when compared to most of the other water based mascaras in the market.
4. Lancome High Definition Mascara:
Now this mascara is a real splurge, but trust me, it’s worth every penny. The product is undoubtedly awesome. It comes with a different type of mascara wand, you may think why am I emphasizing it? Well, it’s because a long wand having thick bristles will help separate your lashes and get rid of any clumps. The formula is really silky and smooth and glides onto lashes like butter. The end result is a superlative look. So, make sure you should choose Lancome if you ever emphasize on getting sublime looks than splurging on mascara. 
Gigi S. DePascale, a user on Amazon, reviewed the product as “The “Cadillac” of mascaras. I have been reviewing beauty items for more than twenty years, and continually I find myself returning to Lancome for this prime formula. Lashes are lengthened, but they never clump. The shades are wonderful. One coat lasts all day, but repeat as needed. Once you try this, it is hard to work with many other mascaras.”
5. Bobbi Brown Smokey Eye Mascara:
It’s the beloved mascara found most commonly in the celebrity makeup artist’s bags everywhere. This water based mascara is precise to pair with your extensions and get the British royal queen-like-look. Bobbi Brown serves up that Smokey eye glamour with finesse. Bobby Brown Smokey is available on Amazon and is priced around $40. I know that’s a little pricey but c’mon it’s Bobby Brown! The product flushes up your eyelashes with just a few coats and the perfectly designed mascara wand makes things much easier for you.
“Great mascara, and I’m picky. First tried the test and now got the full thing. best one I’ve tried, even better than Dior baby doll something,” says Caroline, a user on Amazon.
6. Urban Decay Mascara:
Urban Decay Perversion mascara has a gel-like formula which is oil free and is specially drafted to be free from any kind of nasty dried up clumps. You should pair this mascara with your eyelash extensions because it helps in strengthening the hold of the fake lashes on your natural lashes. It also provides conditioning to the lashes, making them stronger from the inside. The conditioning element, in particular, helps keep the natural lashes healthy and luscious. Urban Decay mascara is available on Amazon.
Delilah Johnson reviews the product on Amazon as “This is the best mascara on the market. I always pull women aside in public who have the longest most beautiful lashes to ask them what mascara they use – and this is the product I hear 9/10 times. I used to pay for eyelash extensions every month and now I don’t need to! The formula doesn’t dry out in the tube even when it’s close to being finished, you only need a few coats, and you can touch up later in the day without clumps. I’m hard to please and totally in love with it.”
7. Lash perfect Mascara:
Lash Perfect mascara is ideal for lash extensions it is specially crafted for them, while still serving up all the looks. Not only does it make your lashes look neat and beautiful, it is also easy to take off since it’s water based. The product is safe for the eyes and will not result in any kind of allergies. A lot of lash extension specialists have stamped their seal of approval on this product.
8. Lash perfect Mascara:
Eyelash Extension Mascara is exclusively manufactured for application over eyelash extensions. It is completely oil-free and safe for your fake lashes since it doesn’t mess up the glue that is used to stick eyelash extensions and fake lashes. You can wear this mascara on your natural eyelashes even if you don’t have extensions on. A great benefit of this product is that you can wear it everyday since it is easily washable. The brush is well designed with specifications that will let you apply the product evenly on your lashes. The result of all the features of this product is fluffy and voluminous eyelashes that are well separated.
“Having tried the Wunderbrow mascara for my extensions and then tried this one, I prefer this mascara 10 times over. This mascara is PERFECT for eyelash extensions! It helps to increase the amount of time I need for refills. Will definitely buy again & highly recommend,” says Nubian Texan, a user of the product on Amazon.
9. Lash perfect Mascara:
This is yet another great mascara to boost volume on top of eyelash extensions. You can use it when you don’t have extensions on as well. The wand is large and has a lash-maximizing brush that coats each and every lash with maximum product. All the volume without getting the lashes stuck to each other. The end result is fluttery, feathery, and voluminous eyelashes that’ll make you look gorgeous. The amazing formula of the product stays put and doesn’t smudge, flake, or form clumps even after hours of application. You can trust this mascara when you go for that day long picnic with your date. The formula is Vitamin-B enriched and it nourishes your eyelashes as you apply it.
“Worth every penny, compared to over the counter cheaper mascaras. Using eyelash extentions for a couple years, my true eyelashes are short. As it nears time for reapplications of lashes, one month later, I use this mascara to plump up what I have left after extensions have slowly fallen off, due to lash cycling. I apply one to two coats & can get my short lashes to look immensely longer & definitely fuller. Almost like I just had extensions just freshly put on. This is truly the best I’ve found & I’m old & have tried a million different mascaras before going to extensions. I have always liked dramatic eyes. This is not waterproof, but needs cleanser & water to remove. I used to use waterproof but this is so much effective, I sacrifice that for this. I highly recommend this product. Once my true eyelashes grow out, I’ll not need extensions…this will take its’ place & be far less expensive,” says an Amazon customer.
Conclusion:
There may be many types of mascara in the market, but there is just one mascara that is perfect for you and your lash extensions, companies like Maybelline are the best choice to invest in water based mascaras. Hopefully, the list above will help you out to choose your extension’s mascara soulmate. What do you think is the best mascaras for eyelash extensions? Which is your favorite brand and what product gave you a bad experience? Share your mascara stories with us in the comments section below.
